Cake Pops
Box of 12 • starting at $36
Freshly Baked Happiness in SWFL
Custom cakes, cookies, and cakepops made to order — because every celebration deserves something sweet.
Signature Treats
Cupcakes
1 dozen • starting at $35
Cookies
Six‑pack • cream‑cheese icing
Customs
Any theme • Made to order
Quality you can taste
We keep the ingredient list short and premium: real butter, Madagascar vanilla, cage‑free eggs, and top‑tier chocolate like Ghirardelli. Everything’s baked in small batches for consistent flavor and clean finishes.
Weekly studio drops
Fresh cookies are stocked at the studio most weeks. For custom orders, send your date and theme — we’ll confirm flavors, pickup, and timing.
Meet Allyson
Hi, I’m Allyson - the baker, decorator, and sprinkle-obsessed perfectionist behind Sugar & Whisk. When I’m not teaching dance, you’ll find me in the kitchen experimenting with new flavors and hand-piping custom designs late into the night.
What started as baking for friends and family turned into a passion project that I now get to share with the whole community. I love taking someone’s idea and turning it into a cake, cookie, or cakepop that makes them smile before they even take a bite.
For me, the best part of baking isn’t just the taste, it’s creating little moments of joy that people remember.
What Customers Say
“Recital weekend cupcakes were adorable, on‑time, and not too sweet. Ordering again for our team party.”
— Studio mom, Fort Myers
— Studio mom, Fort Myers
“She sold out at the studio in twenty minutes. The confetti cookies are the kids’ favorite.”
— Dance parent
— Dance parent
“The birthday cake traveled well and tasted like real buttercream. Clean design, zero leftovers.”
— Brianna P.
— Brianna P.
Place an Order
Use our short Google Form. We’ll reply within 24 hours to confirm details and pickup/delivery.